A noticeable contrast has emerged between the approaches of Sindh and Punjab government leaders towards interactions with healthcare professionals, raising questions about political culture and management styles within the two provinces. While Sindh’s leaders are commended for their respectful and supportive engagements, Punjab’s leadership, particularly from the PML-N, faces criticism for a confrontational and punitive attitude.
During visits to hospitals and medical institutions, leaders from the Sindh government and the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) are frequently observed engaging with doctors and hospital staff in a friendly and respectful manner. They are noted for listening to the concerns of healthcare workers, acknowledging their contributions, and fostering a collaborative environment. Such positive interactions are credited with boosting morale and promoting a culture of mutual respect within Sindh’s healthcare sector.
In contrast, the Punjab government, led by the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and its Chief Minister, is often reported to adopt a more confrontational stance. Reports suggest that these visits are sometimes characterized by public reprimands, harsh language, and a tendency to single out medical staff for broader systemic problems. Actions such as terminating or suspending doctors and staff on the spot—often for issues beyond their control—have contributed to an atmosphere of stress and demoralization among frontline healthcare workers. The use of humiliating behavior to address minor mistakes has further exacerbated the situation, according to observers.
This stark difference in leadership display has sparked debate about the underlying political culture and management practices within the two provinces. Analysts note that while the Punjab government has indeed made significant progress in the health sector, its approach to managing and supporting health professionals warrants reevaluation.
Dr. Mujeeb Rehman, a prominent medical professional, acknowledged the achievements of the Punjab government in healthcare services but pointed out the need for a more constructive and respectful approach in dealing with doctors and hospital staff. He urged higher authorities to address these issues to ensure a healthier and more supportive work environment for medical professionals across the province.
